Israel says it has retrieved the body of a Thai hostage kidnapped and taken into Gaza on Oct. 7, 2023, as it continues its military offensive across the strip, killing at least 22 people overnight, according to health officials.
The prime minister’s office said Saturday that the body of Thai citizen Nattapong Pinta was returned to Israel in a special military operation. Pinta had come to Israel to work in agriculture. He had a wife and son.
Pinta was kidnapped from Kibbutz Nir Oz and killed in captivity near the start of the war, said the government. His body was retrieved from the Rafah area, Israel’s defense minister said.
Israel said it found Pinta’s body based on information received from the hostage task force and military intelligence. The army said he was taken into Gaza by the Mujahideen Brigades, the small armed group that it said had also abducted and killed Shiri Bibas and her two small children.
This undated photo provided by the Hostage’s Family Forum shows Nattapong Pinta, with his wife and son.
Hostage’s Family Forum via AP
A statement from the hostage forum, which supports the hostages, said it stands with Pinta’s family and shares in their grief. It called on the country’s decision makers to bring home the remaining hostages and give those who have died a proper burial.
Thais were the largest group of foreigners held captive by Hamas militants. Many of the Thai agricultural workers lived in compounds on the outskirts of southern Israeli kibbutzim and towns, and Hamas militants overran those places first. A total of 46 Thais have been killed during the conflict, according to Thailand’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Before Pinta’s body was retrieved, three Thai hostages remained in captivity and two were confirmed dead. The fate of Pinta was uncertain until today, according to the hostage forum.
This comes two days after the bodies of two Israeli-American hostages were retrieved. Judith Weinstein and Gad Haggai had been killed on October 7, and their bodies taken into Gaza. They had also lived on Kibbutz Nir Oz, CBS News previously reported. They had also been taken into Gaza by the Mujahideen Brigades.
The retrieval of Pinta’s body comes as Israel continues its military campaign across Gaza. Hospital officials said they received the bodies of nearly two dozen people Saturday.
Four strikes hit the Muwasi area in southern Gaza between Rafah and Khan Younis. In northern Gaza, one strike hit an apartment, killing seven people, including a mother and five children. Their bodies were taken to Shifa hospital.
Israel said Saturday that it’s responding to Hamas’ “barbaric attacks” and is dismantling its capabilities. It said it follows international law and takes all feasible precautions to mitigate civilian harm.
Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the Oct. 7 attack and abducted 251 hostages. They are still holding 55 hostages, around a third of them believed to be alive, after most of the rest were released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Israeli forces have rescued eight living hostages from Gaza and recovered dozens of bodies.
Israel’s military campaign has killed more than 54,000 Palestinians, mostly women and children, according to the Gaza Health Ministry, which does not distinguish between civilians and combatants. The offensive has destroyed large parts of Gaza and displaced around 90% of its population of roughly 2 million Palestinians.
A fresh search effort has been launched for Madeleine McCann, a British toddler who disappeared from her family’s vacation rental in Portugal more than 18 years ago.
Police haven’t disclosed any evidence to explain why they decided to carry out a new search almost two decades later, but they were focusing Tuesday on land around a cottage previously used by the only suspect in the girl’s disappearance, a German man currently jailed in his home country for unrelated rape and sexual assault charges.
Dozens of agents from Germany’s leading domestic law enforcement agency were poring over the ground Tuesday in the Algarve, a southern Portugal region hugely popular with tourists, where Madeleine was last seen.
Search teams on Tuesday scoured undergrowth and an abandoned building, with police hoping to find evidence that could implicate the convicted German sex offender in her disappearance.
Madeleine McCann
Metropolitan Police
Madeleine was just 3 years old when she vanished from an apartment on the Algarve coast where she was on holiday with her family, sparking unprecedented media coverage and a global campaign to find her.
A previous search of a lake near the Ocean Club resort in Praia da Luz in 2023 yielded no results, but on Tuesday, investigators were back in a part of nearby Lagos to hunt for clues.
Several police vehicles with Portuguese and German number plates as well as fire trucks were seen down a cordoned-off dirt road toward the search site, AFP journalists at the scene saw. Portuguese police said about 25 German investigators were present, with the investigation looking at an abandoned building in an overgrown wooded area.
German investigators conduct a new search operation amid the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, at Atalaia, Lagos, in Portugal’s Algarve region, June 3, 2025.
PATRICIA DE MELO MOREIRA/AFP/Getty
The new searches — carried out at the request of German authorities investigating Christian Brueckner, a convicted rapist who is suspected of having killed Madeleine — are expected to last until Friday.
According to the British tabloid The Sun, investigators are equipped with ground radar technology that can scan the ground down to a depth of 15 feet. The area includes a cottage where Brueckner was living and is dotted with wells and ditches, The Sun reported.
Christian Brueckner, the German suspect
A mobile phone registered in Brueckner’s name was traced close to the family’s accommodation on the night Madeleine went missing. He has always denied any role in her disappearance.
The 48-year-old is currently serving a 7-year prison sentence in Germany for the 2005 rape of a 72-year-old American woman in Praia da Luz. He is due to complete his sentence in September.
He was acquitted in October 2024 in Germany in a separate trial for two sexual assaults and three rapes committed in Portugal between 2000 and 2017.
He has not been charged in connection with Madeleine’s case.
Christian Brueckner, right, a suspect in the disappearance of British toddler Madeleine McCann in Portugal, speaks with his lawyer Friedrich Fuelscher as they wait for the verdict in a trial on unrelated sexual assault charges in Braunschweig, Germany, Oct. 8, 2024.
Michael Matthey/Pool/REUTERS
Brueckner, who according to German media had a string of previous convictions, including for sexual offenses, assault and theft before he was convicted of rape, worked as an odd-job man during his 10 years in the Algarve. He also reportedly burgled hotel rooms and holiday apartments.
At the time of Madeleine’s disappearance, he was living in a camper van.
On Tuesday, a journalist from Germany’s RTL television recounted his correspondence with Brueckner and how he had met him in prison.
Brueckner, the journalist said, complained that “half the world” considered him to be a “cruel rapist.” He said he wanted to eat steak and drink beer when he is released from prison.
A former neighbor in Portugal had told Britain’s Sky News in 2020 that Brueckner was “always a bit angry, driving fast up and down the lane, and then one day, around 2006, he just disappeared without a word.”
He returned to Germany in 2007 — the year Madeleine disappeared — settling in Hanover, but still spent time in Portugal.
On May 3, 18 years since their daughter’s disappearance, Madeleine’s parents Kate and Gerry McCann said they were still determined to find out what happened.
“The years appear to be passing even more quickly and whilst we have no significant news to share, our determination to ‘leave no stone unturned’ is unwavering,” they wrote on the findmadeleine.com website. “We will do our utmost to achieve this.”
The investigation into the bitcoin torture case in New York City has revealed gruesome details about the alleged kidnapping and beating of an Italian man for his fortune in the cryptocurrency.
What we know about the bitcoin torture case
The unidentified 28-year-old man managed to escape from his alleged captors on May 23 in the affluent SoHo neighborhood in Manhattan, according to the New York Police Department. Bloodied and not wearing shoes, the man then found an NYPD traffic agent, who alerted police, according to the Manhattan district attorney’s office.
Two cryptocurrency investors, 37-year-old John Woeltz and 33-year-old William Duplessie, have been charged with kidnapping, assault and unlawful imprisonment in the case. They’re being held without bail, and their attorneys didn’t respond to requests for comment from CBS News.
John Woeltz, 37, appears for arraignment in Manhattan Criminal Court after he was arrested for allegedly holding an Italian tourist hostage in an apparent scheme to steal the man’s cryptocurrency fortune in New York City, May 24, 2025.
Curtis Means/Pool via Reuters
When investigators went through the SoHo town house where the man said he was held, they found a saw, crack cocaine, chicken wire, body armor, night-vision goggles, pictures of the man with a gun pointed to his head and ammunition, according to prosecutors.
Woeltz, who is originally from Kentucky, was arrested when police went to the town house. Prosecutors said the large house has eight bedrooms and that Woeltz had the means to flee the jurisdiction if granted bail, with access to a private jet and a helicopter.
Duplessie turned himself in to police on May 27, the NYPD said. His attorney said in court that Duplessie’s involvement in the case is hotly disputed and he decided to turn himself in when he found out about Woeltz’s arrest, CBS News New York reported.
William Duplessie appears in Manhattan Criminal Court for his alleged involvement in a cryptocurrency kidnapping, in New York City, May 30, 2025.
Jefferson Siegel/Pool via Reuters
The Italian man arrived at the town house on May 6, according to prosecutors. The suspects are accused of previously threatening to have the man’s family killed unless he paid them in bitcoin, and the suspects allegedly lured him to New York with an offer to return the bitcoin to him in person, prosecutors said.
The suspects then allegedly held the man captive for over two weeks as they tried to get him to give up the password for his bitcoin wallet.
During that time, the suspects are accused of shocking the man with electric wires, hitting him on the head with a gun and pointing a gun at his head several times, prosecutors said. An AirTag tracking device was tied around the man’s neck, and the suspects allegedly told him they would find him if he left the house.
Prosecutors also said the suspects allegedly hanged the man over the ledge of the building and threatened to kill him if he didn’t give up his password. The suspects also allegedly threatened to have the man’s family killed if he didn’t give them what they wanted, prosecutors said.
The man told authorities the suspects cut his leg with a saw, forced him to smoke crack cocaine and urinated on him during his captivity, according to prosecutors.
“To be tortured for 17 days in terms of a chain saw cutting your leg, in terms of putting your feet in water and electrocuting him, in terms of making the person ingest narcotics, horrible crime,” NYPD Chief of Department John Chell, the police department’s highest-ranking uniformed member, told CBS News New York.
The Manhattan town house where an Italian man was allegedly tortured for weeks in an attempt to gain access to his bitcoin wallet is seen in New York City, May 29, 2025.
Reuters/David “Dee” Delgado
The man escaped after telling Woeltz he would give him the password, but it was on his laptop, prosecutors said. When Woeltz went to get the laptop, the man went downstairs and bolted from the house.
Police sources told CBS News New York that two NYPD detectives did private security work for the suspects, but there isn’t any indication that the detectives knew about the alleged kidnapping. One of the detectives picked up the Italian man at an airport and brought him to the SoHo town house, two sources told CBS News New York.
The detectives were placed on desk duty May 28 and had their guns and badges taken from them pending an internal affairs investigation into the off-duty work, which the NYPD said wasn’t authorized.
One of the detectives was assigned to the security detail for New York City Mayor Eric Adams.
“Every city employee is expected to follow the law, including our officers, both on and off duty,” Kayla Mamelak Altus, Adams’ press secretary, said in a statement. “We are disturbed by these allegations, and as soon as it came to our attention, the officers were placed on modified duty.”
Alex Sundby is a senior editor at CBSNews.com. In addition to editing content, Alex also covers breaking news, writing about crime and severe weather as well as everything from multistate lottery jackpots to the July Fourth hot dog eating contest.
“Are you gonna kill my mommy? Are you gonna kill me?”
Michelle Renee said those are the first words she heard from her 7-year-old daughter Breea after three masked gunmen broke down their door in San Diego County, California, on the night of Nov. 21, 2000.
Renee says she had lost sight of her daughter after the intruders threw them to the floor and bound them with duct tape. When she was finally able to look up, she saw Breea “face down, with a gun to her head.”
The gunmen took their time explaining why they were there. They told her they had followed her for months.
“It was very much that mind control thing that they were doing, that, ‘we know everything about you,'” Renee said, including the fact that she was a branch manager at a local bank.
Finally, the ringleader told Renee what they wanted.
“You’re gonna rob the bank for us,” she recalled them telling her. “Or you will die, your daughter will go first.”
Throughout the night, Renee said she heard the ringleader talking to a female voice on a walkie-talkie. The woman called him “Money One,” and she was “Money Two.”
The following morning, Renee, her roommate and Breea were strapped with dynamite. Renee said they told her they could detonate within a 10-mile radius if she made one false move. Breea would be placed in a closet while Renee drove to the bank —with the ringleader crouched in the back of her car. By the time the bank opened at 9 a.m., Renee walked out with a duffel bag filled with $360,000.
Recovered money from the bank robbery.
North County Superior Court
Once the gunman took off with the cash, Renee raced home, not sure what she’d find once she got there.
“I don’t know if Breea’s gonna be there,” Renee recalled thinking. “I don’t know if she’s gonna be alive when I get there.”
When she finally arrived the gunmen were gone, and Breea was still in the closet where Renee had left her.
In a reenactment for investigators, Michelle and Breea Renee are seen wearing the fake dynamite that the intruders strapped to their backs.
North County Superior Court
The ringleader had forgotten to remove the dynamite from Renee’s back. After examining it, the bomb squad discovered it was fake. Tom Manning, a prosecutor in the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office, told “48 Hours” that it was just two broomstick handles that had been cut up, painted and taped together to look like dynamite.
During the 14-hour hostage situation, Renee had recognized the ringleader’s eyes because he had posed as a customer at the bank earlier that day, and he had left behind a business card before a female companion had whisked him away.
“My brain was going, ‘Oh my gosh, don’t let him know that you know,'” Renee said.
The lead would help investigators crack the case.
“Through that card, they started the investigation,” Renee said.
The business card contained the suspect’s real name, Christopher Butler. The FBI soon discovered Butler was a convicted felon with a history of robbing banks. Through surveillance, they found Butler living in a house with his fiancée Lisa Ramirez, the same woman who had come with him to the bank. When Butler and Ramirez were arrested 10 days later at a traffic stop, investigators found physical evidence tying them to the crime, including a BB gun that matched one of the guns Renee had described, the ski masks with cutout eye holes, Renee’s credit cards, and the money straps from the bank.
At the house, investigators found “all the ingredients to make the fake bomb,” Manning said, like cut-up pieces of a broom handle that had been painted, and cans of red spray paint, including one with Ramirez’s fingerprint on it. Butler’s fingerprint would later be found on the fake dynamite itself.
“It was crazy, I’ve never seen that much physical evidence left at a crime scene,” Manning said.
Butler denied everything to police and tried to protect Ramirez. But during her interview, Ramirez admitted to authorities she was involved in the plot, and that she was the female voice on the walkie-talkie. She even took credit for the idea to use fake dynamite and kidnap the bank manager. She also told detectives the money had been split three ways among the suspects, but that both her share and Butler’s had been stolen. But during that interview, Ramirez also falsely claimed that Renee had been in on it.
“We walked out of that thinking, ‘OK, Lisa’s the mastermind behind all of this. And, is it possible Michelle’s involved?'” Manning said.
But ultimately, Manning said, he knew Renee was innocent.
“The first time I interviewed her, she had Breea with her,” Manning said. “And…I saw that bond and relationship. And when she left, I went, ‘she’s not involved in this.'”
There was also all the evidence to corroborate Renee’s account. The other two suspects, Christopher Huggins and Robert Ortiz, had given full confessions, neither implicating her.
Christopher Butler and Lisa Ramirez, aka “Money One” and “Money Two,” in court during their June 2002 trial.
Zuma
In June 2002, Butler and Ramirez would be tried together in the first of two trials.
“There was so much evidence, there was no way I thought that this trial was gonna be anything but… a slam dunk,” Renee said.
Manning said the DA’s office was confident that Ramirez’s key statements about her involvement would be allowed into evidence.
Even Ramirez’s attorney Herb Weston admitted that it didn’t look good for his client — she had confessed on camera. Weston told Smith he thought Ramirez was guilty when he first got the case, and offered the prosecution a plea deal, which they rejected.
“If they play that tape, saying that she wasn’t involved would’ve been difficult,” Weston told Smith.
But to everyone’s surprise, and Weston’s delight, since Ramirez’s statements also implicated her co-defendant Butler, the judge ruled the entire interview inadmissible.
“We can now argue that she’s not involved,” Weston explained.
Without Ramirez’ statement, the case against her relied heavily on Renee’s testimony. In court, the defense would attack her credibility, and even suggest she was complicit in the bank robbery.
“I was treated like I was the criminal,” Renee said.
Manning remembers that “it got very confrontational.”
Weston told “48 Hours” his strategy was to “beat the hell out of the victim and point out all the inconsistencies the victim is saying.”
He implied Renee was lying about recognizing Ramirez’s voice on the walkie-talkie the night she was held hostage, pointing out that it wasn’t in any of the FBI reports. But Renee insists she told them, and Manning argued Renee did identify Ramirez’s voice before she took the stand. But Weston argued that even though his client had admitted the voice was hers, the jury didn’t know that.
“That’s not the point,” Weston said. “For me, it was a great opening to attack [Renee’s] credibility.”
Weston said it was suspicious that Renee hadn’t taken the bait money — traceable bills banks keep in the vault to trap bank robbers. Renee explained, however, that she was not going to take the chance that she could get her daughter killed, especially since the gunmen had instructed her “no funny money,” she said.
Maybe worst of all for Renee, Weston cast doubt on her maternal instincts, questioning why she would go back to the house, knowing she was strapped with dynamite that could possibly explode. But Manning said Renee’s actions made complete sense, given the stress and the pressure Renee was under to pull off a bank robbery to save her daughter’s life.
While Weston hammered on every decision Renee made that day, Butler’s attorney picked apart her financial history, and even asked her about her sex life.
“They were trying to paint me as somebody that was irresponsible,” Renee said.
“A selfish, terrible mother…that…would do anything for money,” she added.
According to Manning “the defense was to make her a culprit.”
A teary Michelle Renee in court.” I was treated like I was the criminal,” she said.
ZUMA
After Renee’s three grueling days of direct testimony and cross-examination, Butler took the stand. He continued to protect Ramirez as he had in his police interview, but now he told a new, elaborate story, one in which Renee masterminded the bank robbery. And he claimed the two of them had previously had an affair. He said they had met at a grocery store, and that Renee had recruited him for the bank robbery.
Manning admitted it was jaw-dropping testimony, but contended it was all a lie and that the defense didn’t present any evidence to corroborate Butler’s claims.
“If any of this were true, he would’ve thrown Michelle down in a heartbeat in his [police] interview,” Manning said.
But despite the outlandish story, it would seem the defense had done what they set out to do. After deliberating for five days, the jury found Butler guilty of the robbery and kidnapping of Breea and their roommate, but hung 9-3 on the charges involving Renee’s kidnapping.
Manning said one of the jurors had completely believed Butler’s story, while the other two were unsure. Butler would still receive multiple life sentences for all the other charges, but Ramirez would walk away a free woman. The jury found her not guilty on all counts.
“Mind boggling” Renee said. “The fact it was her idea to do this to a mother and a child and laughing and proud of it.”
“It was the best verdict I ever got in my life,” Weston said.
Even though the other two suspects would be easily convicted at their trial a few months later, Renee said she felt revictimized by the defense’s tactics.
“Is it fair to beat up on the victim?” Smith asked Weston.
“Oh absolutely, absolutely,” Weston replied.
Manning said the jury got it wrong on Ramirez. He believed she was “very involved…The investigators kept saying…she was the brains of the outfit.”
It would take two decades, but the truth would eventually come from an unlikely source.
In January 2020, when Christopher Butler became eligible for parole under California sentencing laws, Manning saw an opportunity to ask him about the story he’d told on the stand. Butler recanted his entire testimony, admitting he and Renee never had a relationship.
“It’s about time,” Renee said. “There was never, ever a chance…that I would…have been involved in anything like this.”
Butler was denied parole, but Renee was free.
“In a weird…way, I could breathe…I could exhale, finally, after all these years,” she said.
Robert Ortiz was granted parole in January 2021.
Christopher Butler was granted parole in December 2024.
Christopher Huggins was granted parole in March 2025.
This story originally aired on Feb. 11, 2023. It was updated on May 24, 2025.
The only monsters that had ever scared Michelle Renee’s 7-year-old daughter Breea were make-believe. But on Nov. 20, 2000, just a day before three masked men broke in …
Michelle Renee: She calls me. ‘Mom, there’s somebody outside the window’ … I looked out there. I didn’t see anything. I didn’t see anybody. … So, I just brushed it off.
Michelle and Breea Renee
Michelle Renee
Michelle had chalked it up to her child’s imagination. But this time was different.
Michelle Renee: She saw them looking through the window. They were there the night before.
The same men now held Michelle and Breea at gunpoint in the living room. The gunmen said they’d been following the 35-year-old bank manager for months.
Michelle Renee: It was very much that mind control thing that they were doing, that “we know everything about you.”
Michelle would recount the events inside the house for investigators:
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: “We’re going to be here all night with you to make sure you know exactly what you’re going to do or you will die.”
Throughout the night, the ringleader gave specific instructions about how he wanted Michelle to rob her own bank the next morning:
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: “We’re going to go over this again. This is what you’re going to do … When Brinks gets there, you’re going to get Brinks’ money.”
As she huddled with Breea on the couch, now duct taped, Michelle could hear him talking to a woman on a two-way radio.
Michelle Renee: Money One to Money Two were their –
Tracy Smith: That’s what they called each other.
Michelle Renee: Yeah, they called each other Money One to Money Two.
Money One was the ringleader. Around 11, the voice on the walkie-talkie got his attention: “Car coming up the driveway. The roommate’s there.”
It was their roommate Kimbra.
Michelle Renee doing a videotaped walkthrough for investigators of what happened when she was held hostage at her former house.
North County Superior Court
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: And they put the gun right here in her face, right up her nose, and said, “don’t make us f***ing use this.” … I pushed the guy’s hand out of her face and said, “don’t do this, don’t hurt her.” And he just pointed it right at me and said, “don’t ever f***ing touch me again …”
Michelle realized this might be the last night she ever spent with her daughter.
MICHELLE RENEE VIDEO WALKTHROUGH: It was almost morning. … I just rubbed her hair so she could try to get some sleep.
Michelle Renee: Wondering if that was gonna be the last time I was gonna get to touch her hair and see her sleep … was pretty tough.
In the morning the nightmare would continue.
Michelle Renee: It was like 6 a.m. … he said “Get up. It’s time to get ready for work.”
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: I got dressed and started doing my hair when he came in and stopped me and said, “we need to put the dynamite on you now.”
In a reenactment for investigators, Michelle and Breea Renee are seen wearing the fake dynamite that the kidnappers strapped to their backs.
North County Superior Court
Michelle, her roommate Kimbra, and Breea would all be strapped with dynamite. Then Money One showed Michelle what looked like a doorbell.
Michelle Renee: “This is a detonation device. … you will disintegrate. Your daughter will go first.”
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE:: “One false move, I push this button.” …
And they sat me right here and said, “now we’re going to take your daughter.”
The gunmen put Breea in her bedroom closet.
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: I was just telling her I’d be right back, that everything is going to be fine.
Michelle Renee: “Be brave, Mommy” … that was the last thing she said … before I walked out to go to the bank.
Tracy Smith: Did you feel brave?
Michelle Renee: No.
As two of the gunmen stayed in the house, Money One handed Michelle a briefcase stuffed with a duffle bag before he crouched in the back of her Jeep. With dynamite on her back and a gun to her side, she drove to work.
Tracy Smith (outside of the bank): So, you pull up into your spot … What does he tell you before you get out of the car?
Michelle Renee: “Don’t … don’t f*** this up.”
Tracy Smith: The Brinks truck came at — 8:50?
Michelle Renee: I believe right around 8:50 was the drop, right over here (poins to the left side of the building from the entrance).
That’s when Michelle grabbed her briefcase and headed to the vault.
Michelle Renee: I brought my teller in the vault with me, said … “I’m getting ready to clear out this vault, or my daughter and I are gonna die. This is what’s happened all night.”
Tracy Smith: And you whispered to her “I have dynamite on my back”?
Michelle Renee: Yes. …Yeah, I whisp — I pulled my shirt up.
Tracy Smith: And then you just opened up the duffel bag and started shoveling in money?
Michelle Renee: I did. … My heart was racing. My –”am I fast enough?”
Michelle’s colleagues would alert the authorities, but not before she walked out with $360,000.
Michelle Renee: … Just get to the Jeep. Hurl it in the Jeep —
Tracy Smith: And go.
Michelle Renee: — and just do what’s next.
Money One directed Michelle to get out a few blocks later.
Michelle Renee: And that I would find my Jeep down the street.
She found her car and raced home.
Michelle Renee: I don’t know if Breea’s gonna be there. I don’t know if she’s gonna be alive when I get there … And I went to open the door, and I was just screaming … “Hello? Hello?” … It was eerily silent.
Breea Renee: And I just heard “Breea,” and I remember screaming, “We’re back here, we’re back here.”
Breea was still in the closet right where Michelle had left her.
Tracy Smith: What was that like to hear and see her?
Michelle Renee: Oh my gosh … She was alive. … “I did it. We did it. … we didn’t die.”
Breea Renee: Probably the happiest moment of my life. … But then I could still see the panic on her face.
Michelle Renee: The dynamite’s still on me.
Before leaving, the gunmen had ripped the dynamite off of Kimbra and Breea. So, they cut it off of Michelle’s back before running to the nearest neighbor.
Rick Brown lived up a steep hill.
Rick Brown | Neighbor: I opened the gate, went down the hill real fast, helped them up to the house.I called 911 right away.
911 DISPATCHER: Sheriff’s Department, can I help you?
RICK BROWN: Yes, some neighbors of ours were held hostage … I need somebody out here right away.
Soon, the place was crawling with investigators from the FBI, San Diego Sheriff’s Department, and the bomb squad.
Tom Manning: This is the dynamite that was taken off of Michelle.
San Diego County Prosecutor Tom Manning would lead the task force investigating the case. They quickly figured out the dynamite was fake.
Tom Manning: They realize that it actually is two painted dowels or broomstick handles … But as you can see from a distance and the lighting, plus it’s on your back with the stress of the situation, you’re not gonna take a chance that it isn’t real.
But during the very real 14 hours they were held hostage, Michelle had held onto any detail that might help identify the attackers.
Michelle Renee: Remembering details is just sort of this part of my DNA about people. That was kinda my superpower.
Details like Money One’s eyes.
A sketch of Money One by Michelle Renee. During the 14-hour hostage situation, Renee had recognized the ringleader’s eyes because he had posed as a customer at the bank earlier that day.
CBS News/Michelle Renee
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: When I turned the light on to go to the bathroom … and I saw his eyes in there… I said “those eyes were at my desk; those eyes were at my desk today. Oh my God.”
Michelle says it was a man with whom she’d had an odd encounter at the bank hours before being taken hostage.
Michelle Renee: And he sat at my desk for a really long time asking sorta the same questions over and over. … and then a woman walked in and said, “Chris, we need to get going.” And they got up and left.
The man had handed Michelle his business card.
Tracy Smith: And the name on the business card was?
Michelle Renee: Christopher Butler.
THE EVIDENCE LEFT BEHIND
After hours of police questioning, Michelle and Breea were sent to a hotel. Michelle called her brother Dave.
Dave Estey: It didn’t sound like her … it was — someone, you know, heavily traumatized.
Dave, who lived three hours away, rushed to his sister’s aid.
Dave Estey: What I saw when I opened that door … it scared the daylights out of me. … “Are you OK?” And she would shake.
Tracy Smith: How about Breea?
Dave Estey: Same thing.
In the days ahead, Michelle struggled to hold it together for her daughter – “She was the strongest person for me,” says Breea — while investigators wanted answers.
They grilled her about that odd encounter with Christopher Butler.
Tracy Smith: Why was he in the bank? What was he saying he was there for?
Michelle Renee: He came in to say that he was a potential client. And that he wanted to talk about investments.
Before Butler handed Michelle his business card, a woman he introduced as Lisa came in and whisked him away.
Michelle Renee: “Hey, Chris, we need to go.”
It was the same voice Michelle says she heard later that night on the walkie-talkie.
Michelle Renee: I kept saying it over and over.
Tracy Smith: “Check my desk. Get that card.”
Michelle Renee: “Check my desk. Get that card. …I know that it’s them.”
Tom Manning: Through that card, they started the investigation.
The ringleader had been at the bank hours before the break-in posing as a customer. He had talked to Michelle Renee, the bank manager, about opening a new account and had even left behind a business card before a female companion had whisked him away.
North County Superior Court
The FBI soon discovered Butler was a convicted felon with a history of robbing banks.
Tom Manning: They figured out where he was staying … then the team that I work with set up surveillance.
Butler and his fiancée, Lisa Ramirez, lived in a house just a few miles from the bank.
Tom Manning: Some of the people in the house were tellin’ the police who was there, when they planned it
Within days, detectives identified the two other men. Christopher Huggins –
Tom Manning: He was a big guy, maybe — maybe 6’4″ he’s … gang ties.
And the man who’d held a gun to little Breea — a gang member called “Bones” — real name Robert Ortiz.
Tom Manning: Ortiz was the connection … who got the guns.
On Dec. 1, they decided to arrest Butler and Ramirez during a traffic stop.
When Christopher Butler and Lisa Ramirez were arrested 10 days later at a traffic stop, investigators found physical evidence tying them to the crime, including a BB gun that matched one of the guns Renee had described.
North County Superior Court
Tom Manning (in evidence room): In the glove compartment was a weapon … it’s actually a BB gun … if you look at that in a stressful situation, that looks as real as it can get.
Tracy Smith: What’d they find when they popped the trunk?
Tom Manning: A plethora of evidence.
Tracy Smith: All this.
Tom Manning: All this. … They found the black bag that Michelle described the money being carried in, several pairs of black gloves … and a homemade ski mask.
Tracy Smith: Oh, yeah. Look at the eyeholes there that they clearly cut themselves.
Tom Manning: Michelle’s credit cards were all found in the trunk of the vehicle … and then of course the money straps from the bank.
Also in the trunk, that doorbell “detonator”. And there was even more at the house.
Tom Manning: They found all the ingredients to make the fake bomb. … There were broom handles, which were cut up into small dowels which actually were used in making the fake dynamite. … They also recovered the actual spray cans … Ramirez’s fingerprint was on one of those cans.
Tom Manning: It was crazy. I’ve never seen that much physical evidence left at a crime scene.
Tracy Smith: They thought they’d gotten away with it.
Tom Manning: Yeah.
One thing investigators didn’t find on Butler and Ramirez – any of the bank’s $360,000. But after arresting Huggins that same day, they did recover $93,000 of the cash that he’d stashed away. Huggins confessed and said he’d already spent several grand on a trip to Vegas. The fourth suspect, Robert Ortiz, was on the lam.
When authorities arrested him three months later in Wisconsin, Ortiz still had $32,000 of the bank’s money and gave a full confession.
Tracy Smith: Did Huggins and Ortiz’s confessions corroborate each other?
Tom Manning: Yes, very much so.
Tracy Smith: So, did Huggins and Ortiz’s confessions corroborate what Michelle had told investigators?
Tom Manning: Yes, almost identical.
In his interview with investigators, Christopher Butler denied everything to police and tried to protect Lisa Ramirez.
North County Superior Court
Butler denied everything, even when confronted with direct evidence: his thumbprint on the fake dynamite sticks.
DETECTIVE: We’ve got fingerprints that are yours that link you to the bank robbery.
CHRISTOPHER BUTLER: I doubt that because I wasn’t involved in the bank robbery.
He tried to protect Ramirez.
CHRISTOPHER BUTLER: Lisa wouldn’t have been involved with that.
But Ramirez was about to start talking. She admitted she was the female voice on the walkie-talkie.
LISA RAMIREZ: That was me.
DETECTIVE: That was you?
LISA RAMIREZ: Mm-hmm.
In her interview with investigators, Lisa Ramirez admitted she was involved in the plot, and that she was the female voice on the walkie-talkie. She even took credit for the idea to use fake dynamite and kidnap the bank manager. But during that interview, Ramirez also falsely claimed that Renee had been in on it.
North County Superior Court
She even took credit for the idea to use fake dynamite and kidnap the bank manager.
LISA RAMIREZ: I honestly know whose idea it was, about eight months ago.
DETECTIVE: Who?
LISA RAMIREZ: Jokingly, mine.
Ramirez said they’d split the money three ways, but that her and Butler’s share – more than $100,000 – had been stolen. And to everyone’s surprise, she said Michelle was in on the plot.
LISA RAMIREZ: Supposedly from what they had told me this Michelle lady was helping them.
Tom Manning: We walked out of that thinking, “OK, Lisa’s the mastermind behind all this. And, is it possible Michelle’s involved?”
Manning says, ultimately, he knew Michelle was innocent.
Tom Manning: The first time I interviewed her, she had Breea with her. And … I saw that bond and relationship. And when she left, I went, “She’s not involved in this.”
But that wouldn’t be enough in court. San Diego County Sheriff’s detectives Rudy Zamora, Dale Martin and Randi Demers would have to rule Michelle out as a suspect.
Rudy Zamora: Every time we pushed a button, she would react in a way … a true victim should.
They recreated the dynamite packs and strapped them on Kimbra, Michelle and Breea.
Dale Martin: She was very upset.
And Michelle was emotional when asked to revisit the horrific details of the kidnapping.
FBI VIDEO OF MICHELLE RENEE AT CRIME SCENE: And then they — I had to put her in there and they just shut the — shut the closet.
Dale Martin: She was shaken up. I thought she was gonna have a nervous breakdown.
Tracy Smith: When Michelle did those reenactments, were her story, Kimbra’s story, and Breea’s story consistent?
Tom Manning: Yes. Completely consistent.
In fact, investigators couldn’t find any evidence Michelle was involved. Still, they worried as they took a deep dive into Michelle’s life.
Rudy Zamora: She was not our normal victim.
Tracy Smith: What did they find out about Michelle’s past?
Tom Manning: She didn’t hide anything.
Including the fact that for years she had worked as a stripper.
Michelle Renee: I’m not embarrassed or ashamed by any of that.
Michelle says it was one of the choices she had to make for survival at a young age.
Michelle Renee: I ran away at 15. … I worked really, really hard to get to where I was.
In 2000, Michelle Renee was a single mom working as a bank branch manager. “I was running a bank and I had a career. I was loving where I was living. I really loved my job,” she told “48 Hours” contributor Tracy Smith.
Michelle Renee
With no high school diploma, she had climbed the corporate ladder all the way to regional vice president before taking the bank manager job to be home more with Breea.
Tracy Smith: And while you were working at the bank, you were still dancing, still stripping for a while?
Michelle Renee: I was for a while …The money was really great.
But more worrisome were things that went directly to Michelle’s credibility.
Tom Manning: She falsified resumés … claimed she had various experience, variouseducation which she didn’t have.
Tracy Smith: Bounced a check, filed for bankruptcy.
Tom Manning: Right.
Tracy Smith: That doesn’t look good.
Tom Manning: It doesn’t look good. …And if you’re a defense attorney, you’re lickin’ your chops.
ATTACKED AT TRIAL
By spring of 2001, the suspects were in custody awaiting trial for kidnapping and bank robbery charges, but Michelle and Breea were still reeling from that night of terror.
Michelle Renee: I could still hear them. I could still hear the sounds … I couldn’t get it to turn off.
Breea Renee: I just wanted to hide. I thought they were gonna find us. They were gonna kill us still.
In June, Michelle decided to move Breea to Alaska to live with her grandmother.
Michelle Renee: I was gonna fly her up there and get her to safety … I was gonna figure out what to do from there.
After a few days, Michelle says she had an epiphany.
Michelle Renee: To go back to San Diego and get rid of everything I could possibly get rid of and drive back to Alaska.
With a dog,some cash, and a camcorder, in Julyshe embarked on a 9-day drive to the Last Frontier.
Tracy Smith: You had a deadline.
Michelle Renee: I had a deadline. Breea’s birthday was in nine days. And I’d promised her I’d be back before her birthday party.
Michelle and Breea Renee’s reunion in Alaska was captured by Michelle’s car dashboard camera.
Michelle Renee
That’s when Michelle and Breea say they began to heal.
Tracy Smith: Did you feel safe in Alaska?
Breea Renee: Safer … I could be a kid again.
By the time they returned to San Diego a year later for the trial, Michelle says she was ready.
Michelle Renee: There was so much evidence. There was no way I thought that this trial was gonna be anything but … slam dunk.
Butler and Ramirez would be tried first.
Tracy Smith: When her case came across your desk what did you think at first?
Herb Weston: She’s guilty.
Tracy Smith: You thought she’s guilty?
Herb Weston: Well, yeah.
Herb Weston, who represented Lisa Ramirez, had a problem. His client had confessed on camera.
DETECTIVE: There was a female voice that came out on one of those walkie-talkies.
LISA RAMIREZ: That was me.
Herb Weston: If they play that tape, saying that she wasn’t involved woulda been difficult.
Weston proposed a plea deal, hoping to save Ramirez from a potential life sentence. But the prosecution turned him down.
Tom Manning: We thought we would definitely get the key statements in that she was involved.
But, since Ramirez had also implicated Butler, the judge ruled her entire statement inadmissible.
Herb Weston: We now can at least argue to the jury that she wasn’t involved.
Without her confession, the case against Ramirez relied almost entirely on Michelle — a fact Manning was keenly aware of during his opening statement to the jury on June 3, 2002.
Tracy Smith: You told the jury that this case was about credibility.
Tom Manning: Right…Michelle’s background was gonna be an issue … I knew there were issues … but I believed her.
Tracy Smith: And you thought … the jury would believe her.
Tom Manning: Right.
But not if the defense had its way.
Tracy Smith: What was your strategy going into trial?
Herb Weston: My strategy was to beat the hell out of the victim and show all these inconsistencies that the victim is saying.
Tom Manning: It got very confrontational.
Michelle Renee: I was really, really pissed off.
That played right into Weston’s hand.
Herb Weston: Angry witnesses don’t come across ascredible.
Michelle Renee: I was treated like I was the criminal.
During his cross-examination, Weston implied Michelle was lying about recognizing Lisa Ramirez’ voice on the walkie-talkie.
Herb Weston: Well, wait a minute, ma’am. I’ve looked at all this stuff. … isn’t this the first time you’ve said that?
In fact, he pointed out it wasn’t in any of the FBI reports. But Michelle insists she told them.
Michelle Renee: I did … I 100% did.
And Manning says she identified Ramirez’s voice to him before taking the stand.
Tracy Smith: Does it bother you that Lisa actually admitted that that was her voice on the walkie-talkie? … the fact is it was Lisa.
Herb Weston: But that’s not the issue. … for me it made a great opening to attack her credibility.
Weston then grilled Michelle about bait money — the traceable bills banks keep in their vaults to trap bank robbers.
Tracy Smith: You didn’t take the bait money.
Michelle Renee: Did not take the bait money.
Tracy Smith: Why not?
Michelle Renee: They said … “no funny money.”
Tracy Smith: You say that’s suspicious, that she must have been in on it.
Herb Weston: Correct.
“They were trying to paint me as somebody that was irresponsible,” Michelle Renee said of the three grueling days of direct testimony and cross-examination. “A selfish, terrible mother … that … would do anything for money.”
ZUMA
Maybe worst of all for Michelle, Weston questioned her maternal instincts.
Herb Weston: Would a mother run … to a place where her daughter was … if she believes that “I have a bomb on my back?”
Tracy Smith: She wasn’t sure whether her daughter was dead or alive. Don’t you think it’s possible she wasn’t thinking straight?
Herb Weston: Sure … But also what could be true is she knew there wasn’t a bomb, and so she didn’t have to worry about it.
Tracy Smith: Did you feel like you were on trial?
Michelle Renee: 100% felt like I was on trial.
Dave Estey: I would be sitting in the front row. And all I could think about was … it’s gonna take me … maybe six seconds to get from this point to the offender. … that is how irate I was.
Tracy Smith: Day after day, listening to this.
Dave Estey: Listening to this.
Tracy Smith: Is it fair to beat up the victim.
Herb Weston: Oh absolutely, absolutely.
While Weston hammered on every decision Michelle made that day, the attorney representing Butler went after everything else.
Tracy Smith: What was the worst thing they asked you?
Michelle Renee: About my sex life. …They were trying to paint me as somebody that was irresponsible … A selfish, terrible mother … that … would do anything for money.
And they picked apart Michelle’s finances.
Tom Manning: She’s in … financial distress, and that could be the motive.
Tracy Smith: Isn’t it kinda odd that we’re talking about motive when we’re talking about a victim?
Tom Manning: It is. … The defense in the case was to make Michelle a culprit here.
After Michelle’s grueling three-day testimony, it was Christopher Butler’s turn. He protected Lisa Ramirez on the stand, claiming Michelle was the mastermind, and that they’d had an affair.
Tom Manning: I was shocked.
Michelle Renee: It’s almost laughable.
Tracy Smith: What was his story about how the two of you met?
Michelle Renee: From what I understand … we met in a grocery store and that I recruited him.
Christopher Butler and Lisa Ramirez aka “Money One” and “Money Two” in court during their June 2002 trial.
Zuma
Butler claimed that he’d gone to Michelle’s house that night with Huggins and Ortiz. He said that in the early morning hours while smoking pot, Michelle brought up the bank robbery idea again and decided they should do it that morning.
Tracy Smith: His evidence of this, his proof of this?
Tom Manning: Zero … If any of this were true, he woulda thrown Michelle down in a heartbeat in his (police) interview.
The jury deliberated for five days before finding Butler guilty of the bank robbery and Breea and Kimbra’s kidnapping. But they hung 9-3 on the charges of kidnapping Michelle.
Tom Manning: When we talked to the jurors, you know, we discovered … it was one juror who completely believed Butler and the other two jurors … were unsure.
And they found Lisa Ramirez not guilty on all counts.
Herb Weston: Oh, it was the best verdict I ever got in my life.
Michelle Renee: Mind-boggling. The fact it was her idea to do this to a mother and a child and laughing and proud of it.
Tracy Smith: How involved do you think she was in this?
Tom Manning: Very involved … the investigators kept saying … she was the brains of the outfit.
Tracy Smith: So, the brains of the outfit walked.
Tom Manning: Right.
The second trial would go very differently, with Huggins and Ortiz easily convicted.
Tracy Smith: In so many of the stories that we tell, the ending is the conviction. But in your case, in a lot of ways, that’s just the beginning.
FACING NEW CHALLENGES
Even though the men who had terrorized them were now serving multiple life sentences, Michelle and Breea would never be the same.
Breea Renee: There’s aspects of that night that are gonna be with me for the rest of my life.
They were treated for post-traumatic stress disorder for over two years. Michelle says dealing with the break-in led to a breakthrough.
Michelle Renee: It was two choices. … call them monsters and stay angry … and blame everything in my life on them … Or … I can take this other road.
Michelle Renee: The best thing I could do for Breea is to be an example.
Michelle wrote a book, “Held Hostage,” which was made into a TV movie. And she and Breea went on speaking tours to discuss their experience with trauma.
Tracy Smith: A lot of people coming out of this would want to just forget about it, put it behind them. But you and your mom … talked openly about it.
Breea Renee: Yes. And I think it was the best decision for us.
Breea Renee said by talking about her experience with trauma, “I was showing people that it’s not always the end-all, be-all when something bad happens to you. You can come out of it stronger.”
CBS News
Breea Renee: I was showing people that it’s not always the end-all, be-all when something bad happens to you. You can come out of it stronger.
And by 2011, the girl who had hidden from everything was a high school senior and competitive cheerleader.
Michelle Renee: She really turned the corner and started enjoying her life again.
Michelle Renee: She loved it. It was her absolute passion.
Tracy Smith: You’re thriving. You’re living the dream. You said you dreamed of this. You were living the dream.
Breea Renee: Yes, I was.
Then suddenly …
Breea Renee: Senior year in December, I started feeling a little off. … I was dropping things.
Michelle Renee: Showed up at my work at 6 o’clock, dragging her leg … going “Mommy, something’s really wrong. Something’s wrong. I don’t know what’s happening.”
Breea Renee: I said … “Mom, I’m really scared.”
They had no idea Breea was in for the fight of her life.
Michelle Renee: We rushed her to the hospital. And they started pricking her leg and she couldn’t feel it. And her heart rate started going crazy.
Tracy Smith: Oh my gosh.
Breea Renee: By 8 p.m. that night, I was paralyzed on my left side, couldn’t talk, couldn’t swallow, blind in my left eye.
Michelle Renee: “We found abnormalities in the brain” is all they could tell me that night.
Tracy Smith: It almost sounds like there’s that same feeling of helplessness that you had the night that you were held hostage.
Michelle Renee: Completely.
The next morning, Breea was diagnosed with an acute onset of multiple sclerosis, an autoimmune disease in which the body’s immune system attacks its own tissues.
Michelle Renee: Based on the scans, she has … tumefactive MS, which is not only rare in and of itself, but people Breea’s age at 18 …rarely get MS.
Breea says she was told she might never walk or talk again.
Tracy Smith: Just like that.
Breea Renee: Just like that. … My life just ended again … I was 18 trying to go off to college, do cheer in college, and that was never gonna happen for me.
Tracy Smith: So much of your healing had been talking …. and now you couldn’t talk?
Breea Renee: Now I couldn’t talk … I couldn’t feed myself anymore.
Michelle Renee: She had to relearn all of that.
Diagnosed with a rare form of multiple sclerosis at age 18, Breea Renee was told she might never walk or talk again.
Michelle Renee
But it was as if they had been training for this for years.
Tracy Smith: Do you think in some way what happened to you when you were seven prepared you for battling MS?
Breea Renee: Yes … I think it made me strong enough to go through what I went through with MS.
Michelle Renee: It was here we go again, here we go again.
Breea would spend six weeks in the hospital.
Breea Renee: Two to three times a day of physical therapy, occupational … therapy, speech therapy.
Michelle Renee: After she could talk again … she turned to me and said, “Kidnapping was a piece of cake compared to this.”
And just as with the kidnapping, Breea wanted to inspire others.
Michelle Renee: She wrote her college essay from her hospital room, from her wheelchair and said, “I’m going to college. I am going to be the first person in my family to graduate college no matter what.”
BREEA RENEE (video of her reading college essay in the hospital): I now know that there is no time to waste. Life can change so suddenly.
She chronicled her journey on her Facebook page.
Michelle Renee: She fought tooth and nail every single day for every single step she took. She walked outta the hospital.
This time it was Michelle doing the cheerleading.
Dave Estey: The rehab started … in the hospital. But the real rehab was Michelle constantly on her, “we’re gonna do this.”
Michelle Renee: We were a total team. We just ended up going into full gear. We lived in a house with stairs. … She couldn’t do stairs anymore.
Tracy Smith: So once again, you’re out of a home that you’ve been living in?
Michelle Renee: Right, and I had to … become her full-time caregiver for about a year-and-a half, two years. … and rebuilding our life, again.
Despite the odds, she made it to college.
Michelle Renee: She relapsed three times her first year in college and had to come home. But she did it.
Dave Estey: She follows in her mom’s footsteps … I mean with the tenacity, and the never give up … philosophy that they have.
Breea is walking, talking proof.
“I would say I beat the odds,” said Breea Renee.
CBS News
Tracy Smith: So, they told you would never walk again?
Breea Renee: Yeah. I’d never walk again, never see again, never anything like that…
Tracy Smith: And?
Breea Renee: I would say I beat the odds.
Tracy Smith: Yet again.
Breea Renee: Yes, exactly.
But 20 years after their world first came crashing down, they’d be faced with the unimaginable once again. Christopher Butler could be released.
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT
From the very beginning, the case hit close to home for prosecutor Tom Manning.
Tom Manning: The fact that there was a little girl. My daughter was the same age as Breea when this happened.
Nearly 20 years later, in June 2020, Christopher Butler was up for parole.
Michelle Renee: He’s the one who lied about me.
Manning made sure he was at the hearing.
Tracy Smith: And you had a plan going in.
Tom Manning: I did.
He saw a chance to set the record straight by asking Butler about the story he’d told on the stand.
Tom Manning: I told Michelle if I felt it was right, I was gonna go for it.
Tracy Smith: What’d you think … about that?
Michelle Renee: Go for it … ask away.
Tracy Smith: Even though that’s risky?
Michelle Renee: It’s a little risky … this guy could go to the grave with these lies.
The risk paid off. Butler recanted his whole story, admitting he and Michelle never had a relationship.
Tracy Smith: How did that feel to hear that?
In January 2020, when Christopher Butler became eligible for parole under California sentencing laws, prosecutor Tom Manning saw an opportunity to ask him about the story he’d told on the stand. Butler recanted his entire testimony, admitting he and Renee never had a relationship. Butler was denied parole, but Renee was free. “In a weird … way, I could breathe … I could exhale, finally, after all these years,” she said.
CBS News
Michelle Renee: Hmm … it’s about time … I wanted everybody who ever doubted me to read this parole transcript. I wanna blast it all over the internet … that there was never, ever a chance … that I would ever, ever have been involved in anything like this, ever.
Breea says it’s a bittersweet victory for her mom.
Breea Renee: It feels good, but it’s a little too late. … You can search my mom’s name and it can come up on the internet. You can’t take that back.
Dave Estey: Why is it take him so long to come clean? And it’s probably because he had an opportunity to be free.
Even though Butler was unequivocal that Michelle was not involved –
Michelle Renee: He still hasn’t really taken responsibility.
He blamed his old flame Lisa Ramirez. But Butler said he was sorry for what he’d put his victims through, and even said he’d read Michelle’s book more than once.
Tracy Smith: He … said some of the passages in your book really got to him.
Michelle Renee: Yeah … on the road trip to Alaska … I really started to think about what it would be like to try to just understand.
Michelle says that’s when she started to wonder about the people behind the masks.
Michelle Renee: This is someone’s son. … This is someone’s brother. This is someone’s grandson. …What happened to them in their life that got them to the point where they thought … the only option was to attack a mother and her daughter?
Tracy Smith: Do you accept Christopher Butler’s apology?
Michelle Renee: I do … Yeah, 1000%. … I appreciate him finally being honest after all this time … I hope he keeps digging deeper.
Breea Renee: Yeah. I forgave him a long time ago and I accept his apology.
But neither Breea nor Michelle want Butler released. He’s already been denied parole twice. The irony isn’t lost on Dave.
Dave Estey: All he really did is free everybody else … he’s held hostage with his lie.
Michelle Renee: In a very weird … way, I could breathe … I could exhale finally after all this time.
Robert Ortiz, left, and Christopher Huggins
ZUMA
While they don’t believe Butler has changed his ways, they feel very differently about the other two men who held them hostage.
Breea Renee: They confessed … they take accountability for what they did. And that’s a big thing.
Tracy Smith: Are you actually rooting for these guys to succeed at this point?
Breea Renee: Yes, yes. … They were younger … than what I am now … if they are doing the work, I want nothing but the best for them.
Especially Robert Ortiz.
Michelle Renee: At the sentencing Robert Ortiz is the only one that turned around and looked at me and said, “I’m sorry” … he mouthed it.
They wrote to Ortiz back in 2011 and received a reply 9 years later.
Michelle Renee: Out of respect for him, I’m not going to say everything that’s in the letter. … I can say that … it’s beautiful. … It’s heartfelt. … And … I can’t wait to see where that leads.
Tracy Smith: This is the young man who held a gun to your daughter’s head.
Michelle Renee: Yes, and she spoke at his parole hearing in his favor.
In the meantime, Michelle has written her follow-up bookabout the road trip that changed her point of view.
Michelle Renee: It is about healing … it’s called “Nine Days,” which is how long I was on the road to Alaska.
Dave Estey: I do believe that through this terrible … tragedy that something beautiful was meant to come about. … It has built these people into these incredible human beings.
And through it all, they say they wouldn’t change a thing — even the kidnapping.
Tracy Smith: So, if you look back at the last 20 years, what has this journey been about?
Michelle Renee: Raising a remarkable daughter … It’s the best thing I’ve ever done in my life, is be her mom.
Tracy Smith: It seems like both of you look at this at least a tiny bit as a gift.
Breea Renee: Uh-huh. Yeah … I wouldn’t change it. … it … gave us the chance to build the bond that we have today. And it’s just gotten stronger … Yeah.
Robert Ortiz was granted parole in January 2021.
Christopher Butler was granted parole in December 2024.
Christopher Huggins was granted parole in March 2025.
Produced by Gayane Keshishyan Mendez. Michael McHugh is the producer/editor. Emma Steele, Lauren Turner Dunn, and Danielle Arman are the associate producers. Greg McLaughlin and Diana Modica are the editors. Peter Schweitzer is the senior producer. Nancy Kramer is the executive story editor. Judy Tygard is the executive producer.
Tracy Smith is an award-winning correspondent for “CBS News Sunday Morning” and “48 Hours,” who joined CBS News in 2000. Smith has covered a wide range of subjects, producing revealing interviews with news-making artists to moving, in-depth reporting.
Paris — After a month-long trial, the ten people accused of robbing billionaire celebrity Kim Kardashian were given the last word in the final session of their trial on Friday before the jury retired to consider its verdict. The man accused of being the brains behind the $10 million jewelry heist in 2016 offered “a thousand apologies” in a scribbled note to the court.
Aomar Aït Khedache, 69, is now deaf and largely mute. Prosecutors have called for him to be sentenced to 10 years in prison.
Nine men and one woman have been on trial for their involvement in the brazen armed robbery, facing charges including robbery and kidnapping. The gang was dubbed “the Grandpa Robbers” by French media because most were in their 60s at the time of the heist.
Kardashian was in Paris for Fashion Week in October 2016, staying in a discreet hotel in the center of the city. In emotional four-and-a-half-hour testimony 10 days ago, she told the Paris court she “absolutely” believed she was going to be “raped and killed” when one of the armed, masked robbers grabbed her leg and pulled her toward him as she lay on her bed wearing just a bathrobe.
She was bound with zip ties and duct tape and locked in the bathroom while the robbers searched her room for the expensive jewelry they said they had seen on social media posts by the woman they recognized only as “the rapper’s wife” — a reference to her then-husband Kanye West.
Kim Kardashian leaves the courthouse after testifying in the trial of 10 people accused of stealing millions of dollars’ worth of jewelry from her while holding her at gunpoint during Paris Fashion Week in 2016, in Paris, France, May 13, 2025.
Reuters/Piroschka van de Wouw
During the final session on Friday, the two accused whose DNA was recovered from the scene of the crime, both of whom have admitted to their parts in the robbery, apologized to Kardashian and the court.
Yunis Abbas, 71, who had already apologized directly to Kardashian for contributing to the trauma she said she lives with daily, told the court: “All I have to say is to apologize to you again; I’m sorry for what I may have done.”
He was suspected of being the lookout for the gang, stationed outside the luxury residence known as the No Name hotel.
Khedache, in his scribbled note, also apologized to his son. Harminy Aït Khedache, 38, was accused being a driver for the gang that night. He faces eight years in prison if convicted.
Investigators only found DNA from two of the accused, and in court on Friday, the other eight took to the witness stand to reiterate their claims that they had nothing to do with the crime.
The prosecution has called for 10-year sentences against the four men charged with directly participating in the armed robbery — Khedache, Abbas, Didier Dubreucq, 70, and the youngest of the accused, Marc-Alexandre Boyer, 35.
The prosecutor said in court that they were “experienced robbers who came up with a plan and succeeded.”
Florus Heroui, 52, a Parisian bar manager, and Gary Madar, 36, a waiter and brother of Kardashian’s regular Paris chauffeur, who allegedly fed tips to the gang, both face possible seven-year sentences if convicted.
The only woman on trial, Christiane Glotin, 79, a former companion of the senior Khedache, was accused of being the gang’s “secretary,” taking care of logistics. The prosecution has called for to receive a six-year sentence.
The prosecution called for François Delaporte, who is charged with being an accomplice, to be sentenced to four years in prison, with two of them suspended, and for Marc Boyer, who’s charged with illegal possession of a weapon, to be fined about $23,000. He is the father of Marc-Alexandre Boyer.
Elaine Cobbe is a CBS News correspondent based in Paris. A veteran journalist with more than 20 years of experience covering international events, Cobbe reports for CBS News’ television, radio and digital platforms.
Paris — There was intense security and crowd control measures in place Tuesday at the central Paris courthouse where Kim Kardashian was set to give evidence in the trial over the 2016 armed robbery in which a masked gang made off with $10 million worth of her jewelry as she visited the French capital. The court opened early to allow journalists and members of the public access ahead of Kardashian’s afternoon appearance.
Some 400 reporters applied to attend the trial, but there were only 40 places allocated for media inside the courtroom. A side room was set up for 200 more journalists to watch a live transmission from inside the courtroom. The hearing will not be broadcast publicly, as France rarely allows cameras in courtrooms.
Kardashian’s lawyers said she was determined to testify in person about the night she was allegedly tied up and robbed at gunpoint while she was in Paris for Fashion Week. Ten people — nine men and a woman — face charges including robbery and kidnapping against the American media personality and the concierge of the residence where she was staying on the night of Oct. 2, 2016.
A French police car is seen outside a luxury hotel suite that was rented by Kim Kardashian, and at which she was robbed at gunpoint by masked thieves during Paris Fashion Week, Oct. 3, 2016, in Paris, France.
Marc Piasecki/Getty
Before the celebrity took the stand herself, her longtime friend-turned-stylist Simone Harouche told the court on Tuesday that she heard Kardashian begging for her life during the attack in the hotel suite they were sharing.
“‘I have babies and I need to live!’ That is what she kept on saying, ‘Take everything. I need to live,'” Harouche told the court. “I was scared that she was raped or violated. I thought the worst.”
Prosecutors have told the court that that when the gang, dressed as police officers, arrived at the luxury suites hotel known only as “The No Address” where Kardashian was staying, they demanded that the concierge, at gunpoint, guide them to “the rapper’s wife,” a reference to her then husband Kanye West. The couple settled for divorce in 2022, and West is now known as “Ye.”
Kardashian said that once they got inside the apartment, the masked thieves pointed a gun at her, then bound her wrists and ankles with zip ties and duct tape, all the time demanding in thick French accents: “Ring, ring,” apparently referring to the $4 million diamond ring given to her by West.
In interviews and on her family’s reality TV show, Kardashian has described being terrified during the intrusion, thinking she was going to be raped and killed.
“They dragged me out to the hallway on top of the stairs, that’s when I saw the gun, like clear as day,” she said on her show “Keeping Up with the Kardashians,” adding: “It makes me so upset thinking about it.”
The robbers, some of whom escaped on bicycles, have been dubbed “the Grandpa robbers” as most of the suspects were in their 60s at the time of the heist.
As they fled, they dropped a diamond and platinum cross that was found the next morning by a local resident. The rest of the haul has not been recovered.
The DNA of two of the accused was found at the scene, and they have admitted taking part in the robbery. Aomar Ait Khedache, now 69, is accused of masterminding the heist. Known as “Old Omar,” he reportedly told investigators he had no idea who Kardashian was, but had heard from a waiter friend about the amazing jewelry she wore when she was out dining in Paris.
Defendant Aomar Ait Khedache is seen outside the Palais De Justice court, April 28, 2025, in Paris, France. He is one of 10 people on trial, accused of stealing millions of dollars worth of jewelry from Kim Kardashian, who was held at gunpoint in her hotel suite during Paris Fashion Week in 2016.
Pierre Suu/Getty
Khedache reportedly wrote to Kardashian in 2017, while he was in custody, to apologize. Her lawyers said he wrote after he heard her speak of how traumatic the experience had been. He has not apologized in court.
Yunis Abbas, 71, has admitted that he acted as a lookout for the gang. In court on April 29, he expressed “total regret” for his part in the heist. He said he understood afterward that, “when you steal a lady’s purse, it can be traumatic” for her.
A police officer who testified for the prosecution told the court Kardashian appeared “traumatized” in the immediate aftermath of the robbery.
Lawyers for some of the accused expressed concern as the trial opened last month that Kardashian’s fame would distract from the essentials of the case.
Chloe Arnoux, who represents Khedache, told reporters: “He is, in fact, rather worried about seeing all you, journalists, because he is afraid that his case will not be treated the same way it would be if there were not such a famous person involved in it.”
Kardashian’s lawyer Michael Rhodes said in April that the reality TV star and entrepreneur had ”tremendous appreciation and admiration for the French judicial system,” and ”wishes for the trial to proceed in an orderly fashion in accordance with French law and with respect for all parties to the case.”
Elaine Cobbe is a CBS News correspondent based in Paris. A veteran journalist with more than 20 years of experience covering international events, Cobbe reports for CBS News’ television, radio and digital platforms.
