An employee of the Volkswagen plant in Zwickau stands next to the VW logo on the factory premises during an information event organised by the Works Council of Volkswagen Saxony in Zwickau, eastern Germany, on October 28, 2024.
Jens Schlueter | Afp | Getty Images
A perfect storm of challenges for the European automobile industry shows no sign of letting up, analysts say.
Automakers have struggled to come to terms with a series of headwinds on the road to full electrification, including a lack of affordable models, a slower-than-anticipated rollout of charging points, intense competition from China, tougher carbon regulations and the prospect of targeted U.S. tariffs.
It is against this backdrop, analysts say, that the industry will be bracing for a bumpy ride next year.
Julia Poliscanova, senior director for vehicles and e-mobility supply chains at the campaign group Transport & Environment, described the outlook for European automakers as “quite bleak.”
“They are behind on electrification, their products are just not as good as the formidable Chinese competition – and that is not anyone’s fault but the carmakers,” Poliscanova told CNBC via video call.
Poliscanova highlighted the fact that car sales in Europe remain below pre-Covid-19 levels as the industry continues its struggle with getting to grips with higher interest rates.
Some of Europe’s original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) have expressed concern about the next tightening of carbon regulations, particularly as electric vehicle demand falters.
The European Union’s cap on average emissions from new vehicles sales is poised to fall to 93.6 grams of CO2 per kilometer (g/km) from next year, reflecting a 15% decrease from a 2021 baseline of 110.1 g/km.
Exceeding those limits — which were agreed in 2019 and form part of the 27-nation bloc’s ambition to reach climate neutrality by 2050 — can result in hefty fines.
The European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association, or ACEA, has called on the EU to ease the 2025 compliance costs “while keeping the green mobility transformation firmly on track.”
The car lobby group, which represents the likes of BMW, Ferrari, Renault, Volkswagen and Volvo, said in late November that action is necessary to further support the industry, citing sluggish EV demand and a deteriorating economic climate.
A European Commission spokesperson was not immediately available to comment on calls to provide regulatory relief to carmakers. An EU spokesperson previously told CNBC that the bloc’s executive arm is “sensitive to the challenges that are being faced” by the industry.
What next for Europe’s car giants?
Transport & Environment’s Poliscanova said it is “really frustrating” to see some calling for the European Commission to water down its carbon regulations.
“For me, it is not linked … The car CO2 target is not going to help them in China or sell more cars, that is not the point. The vehicle CO2 target, however, is critical in making them more competitive and making them transition quicker,” Poliscanova said.
“So, it is pushing them, even if it is to the detriment to some of their higher profit margins in the short term, it is pushing them to make the products that are viable in the future,” she added.
A move to delay the fines would be the same as scrapping the regulation altogether, Poliscanova said, warning this would only delay the inevitable, “which is the demise of the European industry.”
“We are behind on electrification. So, how on Earth does delaying the target and making us even more behind going help the industry? I don’t get it. I just don’t get how it helps the transition they have to go through,” Poliscanova said.
Shares of the European auto industry’s so-called “big five” — Volkswagen, Mercedes, BMW, Stellantis and Renault — have broadly plummeted this year, although France’s Renault is a notable exception.
From a financial perspective I’m not expecting much improvement at this point.
Rico Luman
Senior sector economist for transport and logistics at ING
Milan-listed Stellantis has led the losses, down 37% year-to-date, with Germany’s crisis-stricken Volkswagen falling 23% and Munich-headquartered BMW tumbling 21% over the same period.
Renault, meanwhile, has notched gains of 19% amid hopes the carmaker might fare better than its rivals due to its relatively limited exposure to China and U.S. markets.
‘Not expecting much improvement’
“Automotive stocks are having a hard time globally,” analysts at Deutsche Bank said in a research note published Dec. 9.
“Unfortunately, we believe the industry is likely to head into another year of volatility and headwinds across regions. We expect more noise of potential policy implications in the US, further restructuring announcements in Europe, muted demand ex China and pricing to soften,” they added.
This aerial photo taken on June 28, 2024 shows newly-produced BMW cars parked at a factory in Shenyang, in China’s northeastern Liaoning province.
Str | Afp | Getty Images
Rico Luman, senior sector economist for transport and logistics at Dutch bank ING, shared a pessimistic view on the outlook for Europe’s OEMs.
“From a financial perspective, it won’t be better I’m afraid because [EVs] are less profitable models in the end,” Luman told CNBC via video call.
“They tend to focus on conventional hybrids much more and also plug-in hybrids because of the profitability there. So, if they are forced to shift more to fill EVs then it will affect profitability. So, from a financial perspective I’m not expecting much improvement at this point,” he added.
‘What people need is cheaper EVs’
Several of Europe’s biggest carmakers unveiled a flurry of low-cost EVs at the Paris Motor Show in October, seeking to jump-start a demand slump and recapture some of the market share now held by Chinese brands.
It was hoped at the time that the new models could represent a turning point for the region’s auto industry.
Horst Schneider, head of European automotive research at Bank of America, said some leeway from European lawmakers may be necessary to support carmakers next year, even though the companies have had years to prepare for the new carbon regulations.
“Most carmakers are running behind, maybe except BMW and Stellantis. Volkswagen has got the biggest gap because it is also the largest carmaker and most exposed to [Internal Combustion Engines]. The EV launches have flopped, kind of, but also Renault is under pressure,” Schneider told CNBC’s “Street Signs Europe” on Dec. 6.
“So, therefore, I would say all the mass market carmakers – expect Stellantis – are under pressure, just because the EV prices are still sitting too much above the ICE price, it is something like 20% or 25%,” Schneider said.
“What people need is cheaper EVs. They get launched in the course of 2025, so some carmakers are saying there is no need really to cut the targets – but I think in general it is good to give the carmakers more time because acceptance on the consumer side is just not yet there,” he added.
